Timor-Leste opts for stability over anticorruption in presidential choiceBY Damien Kingsbury
Last week’s presidential elections, which saw Fretilin’s Francisco ‘Lu-Olo’ Guterres elected president, have set the battleground for parliamentary elections later this year, writes Damien Kingsbury
In a red jacket tightly zipped against the ‘cool’ of the morning, Alberto da Silva stood on a rise above the village of Leohitu last week, surveying voters lined up for Timor-Leste’s first presidential election since United Nations peacekeepers left the country in 2012.
Situated at the end of an often shaded valley, Leohitu has one point of running water for its community and remains part of Timor-Leste’s 20 per cent or so of the population who still do not have electricity.
Of the six villages in the subdistrict, Leohitu—at the end of about six kilometres of variable dirt road—was one of the four accessible by vehicle at the end of the wet season. In some villages, voting materials had to be taken into polling stations by packhorse or on foot.
Leohitu is relatively prosperous by local standards, with fertile soil and a good supply of ground water, even at the end of the wet season.
Having already voted, Alberto da Silva was now talking to an Australian volunteer dentist who, a few days before, had removed four of Alberto’s teeth. Alberto pointed to his mouth with a big gap-toothed smile.
Alberto was very interested in the presidential elections, having run as a Fretilin candidate in the 2016 village elections. He had lost to the Democratic Party (PD) candidate. This part of Timor-Leste tends to be a PD stronghold and Fretilin lost popularity soon after the country gained independence in 2002, marking part of the politico–geographic divide that was evident in the troubles of 2006.
Losing his bad teeth had immediately diminished Alberto’s pain and improved his health, as it had with many others who had benefited from the volunteer dentist’s work. Timor-Leste has less than a handful of dentists and healthcare remains low on the government’s spending priorities. Dental care is generally not available.
Healthcare received just 4.2 per cent of Timor-Leste’s budget in 2016–17. There is one hospital in the capital, Dili, and rudimentary hospitals in the next biggest towns of Baucau and Maliana, with basic health clinics in subdistrict capitals. Two or three dental practices operate privately in the whole of the country, supplemented by occasional volunteer dentists.
With the beginning of the decentralisation of state functions to municipalities, the Bobonaro municipality president, Zeferino dos Santos, identified his priorities as securing a regular water supply and improving roads and access to education. Healthcare ran a distant fourth.
In a country in which local water supply is often seasonal, access to potable water is critical, yet infrastructure remains underdeveloped. Education remains basic, particularly in the outlying villages. Some children walk several kilometres to go to school.
Roads, however, have been a major government priority, along with other infrastructure. A few days before the elections, Timor-Leste’s former president, prime minister and resistance leader, now Minister for Planning and Strategic Investment, Xanana Gusmao, sat beside an expensive new section of the winding, cliff-hugging coast road to the Indonesian West Timor border, staring morosely into a large gap where several metres of road had slid into the sea below.
Everyone in Timor-Leste agrees that roads are a priority in order to facilitate trade and communication. Road conditions are, however, often poor and sometimes impassable. The northern coast road was intended to be an infrastructure showpiece. Yet the island’s unstable geology conspired against it, as it has always done.
Road building has been a major source of government spending until this year, when infrastructure spending was slashed. It has also been a major source of lucrative non-tendered contracts, budget blowouts and, allegedly, corruption.
Xanana Gusmao was surveying the landslide following a trip to the Timor-Leste enclave of Oecussi, in Indonesian West Timor, where the government is building a casino in the hope of attracting gamblers from Indonesia and China. Oecussi is otherwise the most impoverished part of a very poor country. The casino project, being overseen by Fretilin head Mari Alkatiri, also featured regularly on the corruption rumour mill.
In the presidential election on 20 March, Xanana Gusmao’s National Council of Timorese Resistance (CNRT) strongly supported the candidacy of Fretilin’s Francisco ‘Lu-Olo’ Guterres. Fretilin and CNRT form the current coalition government, following their reconciliation two years ago. The choice of Lu-Olo as president in part reflected ‘his turn’ as a senior former resistance fighter who had not yet enjoyed a senior government post.
But, more importantly, it also signalled Fretilin and CNRT’s intention to again rule together should they be successful in the forthcoming parliamentary elections, expected in early July 2017. In part reflecting Fretilin’s locked-in support base of around 29 per cent of the voting public, and Xanana Gusmao’s role as ‘king or king-maker’, it was unsurprising that Lu-Olo was elected president and only slightly less unsurprising that he managed a clear majority of 57 per cent in the first presidential round, thereby avoiding a run-off election.
Outgoing president Taur Matan Ruak and his recently created People’s Liberation Party (PLP), formally headed by former anticorruption commissioner Aderito Soares, say that fighting corruption is their priority. In the presidential election, the PLP supported current education minister and PD candidate Antonio da Conceicao. Interestingly, given the PLP’s public position, da Conceicao’s name has also been circulating in the corruption rumour mill.
With no electoral history, it was unclear how a PLP-supported candidate would fare, although PD’s personally popular presidential candidate Fernando ‘Lasama’ de Araujo polled 17 per cent in 2012. However, with de Araujo’s death in 2015, it was thought PD’s vote would decline, perhaps closer to the 11 per cent it polled in 2007.
That da Conceicao ended up with 33 per cent of the vote was a strong outcome. The remainder of the vote was shared by six other candidates, including one woman, Angela Frietas of the leftist Timorese Workers Party, who received less than 1 per cent of the vote.
The presidential vote was important because Timor-Leste’s president, although largely ceremonial, acts as a balance against the occasional excesses of the executive and the legislature.
The country has been using capital from its US$16 billion sovereign wealth Petroleum Fund at almost 200 per cent beyond sustainable, interest only, limits. At this rate of spending, Timor-Leste will be flat broke within a decade
But most importantly, Timor-Leste’s presidential elections shape the battleground for the later parliamentary elections, and the likely prospects of the respective parties. Despite problems with access to potable water, poor roads, limited educational opportunities and very basic health care, the issues for 2017 revolved around ‘stability’, offered by Fretilin and CNRT, and corruption, opposed by PLP and PD.
Based on the results of the presidential election, it appears that ‘stability’ will likely remain in place after the parliamentary elections, not least because Xanana Gusmao remains the towering figure in Timor-Leste’s politics. Positively, for those who value plural politics, the PLP and PD are likely to form a viable opposition, especially if joined by the other even smaller parties.
Timor Sea dispute
While all parties appear committed to achieving an equidistant boundary in the Timor Sea dispute with Australia based on the principles of the Convention of the Law of the Sea, Lu-Olo was ambiguous on the subject. This is set against a major reduction in infrastructure spending between 2015–16 and 2016–17 and an overall budget reduction of about 15 per cent.
Timor-Leste’s economy runs on receipts from the Timor Sea oil fields, which are now drying up. The country has been using capital from its US$16 billion sovereign wealth Petroleum Fund at almost 200 per cent beyond sustainable, interest only, limits. At this rate of spending, Timor-Leste will be flat broke within a decade.
It is uncertain whether a win for Timor-Leste in the Timor Sea will produce its original intended goal of onshore liquid natural gas processing, in turn intended to kickstart a petrochemical industry. However, certainty around the Timor Sea may see other less grandiose options open up which, with more modest spending, could stave off financial ruin.
Neither side of Timor-Leste’s politics debate this matter in public and it is not an election issue. But, over the next five years, this will be, overwhelmingly, the most important issue for the incoming president and the new government.
Having a viable opposition will at least help enhance accountability on this most critical issue, even if the relative neglect in the regions and their immediate needs is unlikely to substantially change.
Old men waiting to vote at Leohitu. Photo: Damien Kingsbury
- 27th March, 2017